Filed under Running the firm

Can you pay a marketing agency per signed case? What the fee-sharing rules say

Per-case pricing sounds like the fairest deal in legal marketing. Why most ethics rules point the other way, which payment structures are safer, and what changes in Arizona and California.

  • By Advertise Naked
  • Published
  • 10-minute read
  • 11 sources

The short answer

In most states, probably not in the form agencies usually propose. A lawyer may pay the reasonable cost of advertising and may pay for leads, but may not pay anyone for recommending the lawyer or share legal fees with a non-lawyer. Ethics opinions in Florida, New York and other states treat charges per accepted case, or tied to the fee or the recovery, as the risky end. A flat fee, or a fixed price per lead that doesn’t depend on whether the person hires you, sits on much firmer ground.

On this page 10 sections
  1. The two rules that decide it
  2. How ethics committees have applied them
  3. Why “per signed case” usually fails the test
  4. How you pay is only half of it
  5. Arizona, California and the edges of the rule
  6. Safer ways to align an agency with outcomes
  7. Questions to ask before you sign
  8. Key takeaways
  9. Questions
  10. Sources and notes

Every few months an agency pitches a plaintiff firm the same deal: no retainer, no management fee, just a price for each signed case. It sounds like the most aligned offer in the market. The agency only gets paid when the firm does.

The difficulty is that lawyers aren’t allowed to pay for clients the way other businesses can. Two professional rules, adopted in some form in every state, sit underneath the question. This article explains what they say, how ethics committees have applied them to marketing fees, and which structures are safer.

The two rules that decide it

No paying for recommendations. ABA Model Rule 7.2(b) says a lawyer shall not give anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer’s services, with listed exceptions. The first exception is paying “the reasonable costs of advertisements or communications” the rule permits.1

No sharing legal fees with non-lawyers. Model Rule 5.4(a) says a lawyer or firm shall not share legal fees with a non-lawyer, with narrow exceptions such as payments to a deceased lawyer’s estate and firm-wide compensation plans for staff.2 The stated purpose is to protect the lawyer’s independent professional judgment.

A comment to Rule 7.2 ties the two together for marketing. It says a lawyer may pay others for generating client leads, including internet leads, as long as the lead generator doesn’t recommend the lawyer, the payment is consistent with Rules 1.5(e) and 5.4, and the generator’s communications aren’t false or misleading.1

So the test for any marketing fee has two parts. Is it a cost of advertising, or a payment for a recommendation? And does it share in the legal fee?

How ethics committees have applied them

The ABA Model Rules are a template. Each state adopts its own version and its own ethics opinions interpret it. The opinions below are advisory, but they show a clear pattern.

How state ethics opinions have tended to treat each way of paying a marketer.
  1. Flat fee per month or yearGenerally permissible
  2. Fixed price per click or per viewGenerally permissible
  3. Fixed price per lead or referral, owed whether or not you’re hiredOften permissible, with conditions
  4. Flat price per case accepted or retainer signedOften impermissible
  5. Price that varies with the case’s value or type, unless costs truly differOften impermissible
  6. Percentage of the fee or the client’s recoveryImpermissible fee sharing

Advisory opinions, not rules. Your state’s version of the rules decides; ask your ethics counsel.

Florida. In Advisory Opinion 18-1, The Florida Bar’s Board of Governors listed fixed periodic charges, pay-per-click charges, and fixed per-referral charges that don’t depend on the outcome or the amount at issue as generally permissible. It listed charges calculated as a percentage of the lawyer’s fee or the client’s recovery, charges based on the perceived value of a case, and “a flat charge per case accepted” as generally impermissible.3 The Florida opinion also noted that most other states that had looked at similar programs concluded lawyers may not pay a set fee for each accepted case.

New York. New York’s ethics committee first held that a lawyer couldn’t pay a marketer based on the number of clients it introduced (Opinion 902, 2012).4 It later allowed paying a lead service a fixed fee per lead, overruling part of that opinion, on three conditions: lawyers are matched to leads by transparent, mechanical methods; the service doesn’t recommend any lawyer; and the fee doesn’t depend on whether the lawyer is retained or on the size of the fee (Opinion 1131, 2017).5 In March 2026 it applied the same three conditions to a platform selling per-contact credits for employment leads (Opinion 1294).6

Maryland, Ohio, South Carolina, Indiana and others. Several committees reviewed online legal-services programs between 2016 and 2018 that charged lawyers a “marketing fee” for each matter. They found the fee looked like fee sharing or a referral payment, not advertising cost, when it was owed only after the lawyer was hired or varied with the legal fee. Maryland’s committee put it directly: a fee contingent on a client retaining the lawyer, and varying with the fee, is fee sharing.7

Why “per signed case” usually fails the test

Look at a per-signed-case price through the two rules.

  • It’s owed only when someone hires you. That ties the payment to the client relationship rather than to the advertising. Florida listed exactly this structure as generally impermissible.
  • It often varies by case type. An agency that charges more for a trucking case than a slip-and-fall is pricing the case, not the ad. Florida allows type-based differences only where the marketing and administrative costs genuinely differ.
  • It’s easily one step from a percentage. Some offers start as a flat price per case and add a “bonus” on large settlements. That is the clearest form of fee sharing.

The structure also creates incentives the rules were written to prevent. A marketer paid only on signed cases has a reason to push the firm to sign weak cases, to make promises in ads, or to buy leads from sources the firm wouldn’t approve.

How you pay is only half of it

Even a permissible fee doesn’t make the marketing permissible. The ABA’s Formal Opinion 501 considered a firm paying a lead generator a flat monthly fee for mass tort leads. The generator’s staff found people in online groups and phoned them. The opinion concluded that live, person-to-person contact was prohibited solicitation, and that a lawyer who learns how the leads are generated and keeps accepting them is responsible too.8

Before signing with any marketer, find out how the leads are generated, on which channels, and what’s said to people in your name.

Arizona, California and the edges of the rule

Arizona eliminated its version of Rule 5.4 effective January 1, 2021, and created a licensing program for alternative business structures, entities in which non-lawyers can own an interest and share fees.9 Some marketing and litigation-finance companies have set up licensed Arizona entities since.

California went the other way. A 2025 law bars California lawyers from sharing contingency fees with out-of-state entities that provide legal services and allow non-lawyer ownership or decision-making, with exceptions such as fixed-fee arrangements, for contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2026.10 California workers’ comp adds another layer: Labor Code §3215 makes it unlawful to pay for referring workers’ comp clients.11

If an offer routes payment through an entity in another state, ask which state’s rules apply to the lawyer, the client and the fee. Usually more than one does.

Safer ways to align an agency with outcomes

You can keep an agency accountable for signed cases without paying it per signed case.

  1. Pay a flat fee by scope. Band it by ad spend or by the number of channels and markets, agreed in advance.
  2. Pay the platforms directly. Ad spend goes from your firm to Google and Meta, so there’s no markup and no blended number.
  3. Measure cost per signed case every month. By practice, counted by the month the lead arrived, with and without fees. See cost per signed case.
  4. Make the contract easy to leave. A defined first term, then month to month. An agency that can be replaced has every reason to perform.
  5. Review every ad before it runs. The firm carries the professional responsibility, whoever writes the ad.

If you buy leads as well, keep the price fixed per lead, independent of whether the person hires you, and get the seller’s methods in writing. Our owned vs bought leads article covers how to compare the two.

Questions to ask before you sign

0 of 5 done

Then send the contract and the answers to your ethics counsel. Most state bars also run an ethics hotline for exactly this kind of question.

Key takeaways

  • Two rules decide it: no paying for recommendations (Model Rule 7.2(b)) and no sharing legal fees with non-lawyers (Model Rule 5.4(a)).
  • Flat periodic fees and fixed per-lead or per-click prices are the structures ethics opinions most often accept.
  • A charge per case accepted, per signed retainer, or as a share of fees or recoveries is where opinions most often say no.
  • Arizona allows non-lawyer fee sharing through licensed entities; California barred its lawyers from sharing contingency fees with out-of-state ones from 2026.
  • Judge an agency on cost per signed case. Don’t pay it on cost per signed case.

Questions

Isn't paying per signed case just paying for results?

That’s the appeal, and it’s why the question comes up. The problem is what the payment is tied to. A charge that exists only when a client hires you looks, to most ethics committees, like payment for the referral or a share of the fee, rather than the cost of advertising.

Is a fixed price per lead allowed?

Often, yes. Florida’s Bar listed fixed per-referral charges among the generally permissible methods, and New York has approved per-lead payments to a lead service, both on conditions: the price doesn’t depend on whether you’re hired or on the value of the case, and the service doesn’t recommend you.

What about a bonus for our in-house marketing manager?

That’s a separate question. Model Rule 5.4 lets a firm include non-lawyer employees in a compensation or retirement plan based on profits. New York’s opinions allow bonuses tied to overall results but not to the fee from a particular case. Check your state’s version.

We're in Arizona. Does any of this apply?

Arizona removed its Rule 5.4 in 2021 and licenses alternative business structures, so fee sharing can be lawful there through a licensed entity. If the case, the client or your other offices touch another state, that state’s rules may apply too.

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by state and change often. Check the current rule in each state where you advertise, and confirm your setup with ethics counsel before relying on it.

Sources and notes

Checked November 14, 2026. Numbers in the text link to the source they come from.

  1. American Bar Association, Model Rule 7.2, Communications Concerning a Lawyer’s Services: Specific Rules, including the comment on paying for lead generation. ↑1↑2

  2. American Bar Association, Model Rule 5.4, Professional Independence of a Lawyer. ↑

  3. The Florida Bar, Ethics Opinion 18-1, December 14, 2018. Advisory opinions are not binding. ↑

  4. New York State Bar Association Committee on Professional Ethics, Opinion 902, January 13, 2012. ↑

  5. New York State Bar Association Committee on Professional Ethics, Opinion 1131, August 2017. ↑

  6. New York State Bar Association Committee on Professional Ethics, Opinion 1294, March 11, 2026. ↑

  7. Maryland State Bar Association Committee on Ethics, Ethics Docket 2016-14. The Florida Bar’s Opinion 18-1, above, lists the comparable opinions from Indiana (1-18), New Jersey (732), New York (1132), Ohio (2016-3), Pennsylvania (2016-200), South Carolina (16-06) and Utah (17-05). ↑

  8. American Bar Association, Formal Opinion 501, Solicitation, April 13, 2022. ↑

  9. Arizona Supreme Court, press release on rule changes, August 27, 2020, effective January 1, 2021. ↑

  10. California Assembly Bill 931 (Kalra), Chapter 565, Statutes of 2025. The narrowing to contingency fees is described in Bloomberg Law, “California Bans Contingent Fee Sharing With ‘Alternative’ Firms,” October 12, 2025. ↑

  11. California Labor Code §3215. ↑

Bring last month’s numbers.

In 30 minutes you’ll know your cost per signed case, or exactly what’s missing to work it out.

(310) 461-4824

Prefer to talk now? Call during business hours in Los Angeles. Bring last month’s ad spend and signed cases if you have them.