Filed under Click, Inquiry, First contact
Criminal defense marketing: who gets arrested, when they call, and what a missed night call costs
Criminal defense clients often call at night, sometimes through a relative, with a court date already set. This guide starts from FBI arrest estimates, federal jail data and crash research, then follows them into after-hours intake, channels, the ad rules and reporting.
7,570,249 arrests
- Drug violations845,03111.2%
- Driving under the influence798,56310.5%
- Larceny-theft696,8609.2%
- Burglary, vehicle theft, arson171,4702.3%
- Violent crimes413,9915.5%
- Everything else4,644,33461.3%
Driving under the influence alone was 798,563 arrests, about 2,200 a day.
The short answer
Answer at night. Police made an estimated 7.57 million arrests in 2025, 798,563 of them for driving under the influence, and in fatal crashes, drivers are three times as likely to be impaired at night as by day. Across practices, about one in five calls to a law firm arrives after hours, and firms that couldn’t book a consultation on the spot converted 7% of qualified after-hours callers. So reach night callers as often as daytime ones, build pages by charge and county, describe the service rather than the reader’s record, measure by charge in your own records, and check every ad and mailer against your state’s rules.
On this page 11 sections
- How many people are arrested
- When the calls come
- What a missed night call costs
- Where criminal defense clients come from
- Intake for criminal defense callers
- Rules that bite criminal defense marketing
- Measure criminal defense marketing by charge
- A criminal defense marketing check
- Key takeaways
- Questions
- Sources and notes
Criminal defense marketing runs on a different clock. The person who needs you may have been arrested a few hours ago. The call may come from a parent or a partner, at two in the morning, with a court date already set. A firm whose phones stop at six misses those calls, however much it spends on ads.
This guide starts from the FBI’s arrest estimates for 2025, federal jail data and NHTSA research on when impaired driving happens. It follows them into after-hours intake, channels, the ad rules and reporting. It’s for partners and marketing leads at criminal defense and DUI firms. It covers marketing, not the law: each state sets its own rules, so check them where you practice.
Section 1: How many people are arrested
Police made an estimated 7,570,249 arrests in 2025. The FBI’s three most common arrest offenses were drug violations, at 845,031, driving under the influence, at 798,563, and larceny-theft, at 696,860. Violent crimes accounted for 413,991.1 The cover above shows the mix. The offenses it names are about four arrests in ten, and the rest are spread across everything from simple assault to disorderly conduct.
Driving under the influence alone works out to about 2,200 arrests a day. It’s one offense with searches of its own, so it can carry its own pages, campaigns and reporting.
Jail data tells a similar story. Local jails reported 7.9 million admissions from July 2023 to June 2024. At midyear 2024, 68% of the people they held hadn’t been convicted: they were awaiting court action on a charge or held for another reason.2
Three things follow for marketing:
- The charge sets the search. Many searches name the charge and the place: a DUI lawyer in a county, a theft charge in a city. Build pages and campaigns the same way.
- Volume isn’t value. A misdemeanor and a felony each count as one client. Track fees by charge, as our injury guide does for case types.
- The caller may not be the client. Sometimes a relative calls for someone in custody, as our intake guide notes. Intake has to handle both.
Section 2: When the calls come
Arrests don’t keep office hours. NHTSA’s crash data shows when impaired driving happens. In fatal crashes in 2024, 31% of drivers at night were alcohol-impaired, against 10% by day. From Friday evening to Monday morning it was 28%, against 15% during the week.3 Those figures measure fatal crashes, not arrests, but they point to the nights and weekends when many DUI cases begin.
Calls follow. Across practices, about one in five calls to a law firm comes in after hours, in Smith.ai’s data. Firms that couldn’t book a qualified caller on the spot converted 12% of them, and 7% after hours.4 Your own call log will show whether your calls skew later than that.
Section 3: What a missed night call costs
The check below compares how often you reach people in office hours with how often you reach them after hours, and prices the gap. Enter your last full month.
Clients missed after hours4.1
Fees they would bring$18,563
- New clients a month now
- 25.9
- After-hours inquiries a month
- 30
- Clients that cover the cost
- 0.7
Reaching after-hours callers as often as daytime ones would add about 4.1 clients and $18,563 in fees a month. At $3,000 a month, coverage pays for itself with 0.7 more clients, leaving about $15,563.
How it’s calculated
- After-hours inquiries = inquiries × the share that arrive after hours
- New clients now = office-hours inquiries × reached in office hours × hire rate + after-hours inquiries × reached after hours × hire rate
- Clients missed after hours = after-hours inquiries × (reached in office hours − reached after hours) × hire rate
- Fees they would bring = clients missed × average fee per client
- Clients that cover the cost = monthly cost of coverage ÷ average fee per client
It assumes people who call at night hire you as often as daytime callers once they’re reached. Check that in your own records: some night callers are more urgent, and some are only shopping.
It’s deliberately simple. It assumes people who call at night hire you as often as daytime callers once someone reaches them, so check that in your records before you rely on it. If the gap is real, closing it adds clients from inquiries you’ve already paid for.
Section 4: Where criminal defense clients come from
- Search reaches people at the moment they need a lawyer. Build campaigns and pages by charge and county: DUI, drug possession, theft, assault and the rest. Name the courts you appear in, and say how your fees work. Decide whether searches for public defenders and bail bonds are customers, and add them as negatives if not. Our Google Ads guide covers structure and negatives.
- Local Services Ads include criminal, DUI and traffic lawyer categories, and charge per lead rather than per click.5 See our Local Services Ads guide.
- Meta bars ad copy that asserts or implies a criminal record. Its own examples reject asking whether the reader is a convicted felon, and allow offering services to clean up past offenses.6 Meta also lists crime among its US social issues, so an ad that argues about incarceration or sentencing needs authorization and a “Paid for by” disclaimer, while an ad for your service may not.7 It suits record clearing and name recognition better than urgent cases. See our Meta ads guide.
- Record clearing, where your state allows it, is a market of its own. People search for expungement or sealing on their own schedule, so it suits content, search and Meta rather than late-night intake.
- Referrals from other lawyers and past clients are a channel too. Ask every new client how they found you, and report referrals beside paid sources.
Section 5: Intake for criminal defense callers
- Answer at night. Have a person who can explain what happens next, the fee and the next step, at every hour your ads and listings run.
- Settle who the client is. The caller may be a parent, a partner or a friend, and the person paying may not be the client. Establish who the client is, and what you can discuss with the caller, before the conversation goes further.
- Keep jail calls to logistics. Calls from a jail phone may be recorded. Use them to arrange a private conversation, and save the facts for that.
- Check conflicts first. Ask for the names of any co-defendants and alleged victims before the caller tells the story.
- Book on the call. Say how long the consultation lasts and what it costs, and book it before you hang up. In Smith.ai’s data, firms that booked qualified callers on the spot converted 64% of them.4
- Answer in the caller’s language. Run Spanish ads only while a Spanish speaker can answer.
Section 6: Rules that bite criminal defense marketing
- Ad copy. Describe the service, never the reader’s record, and make no promise about outcomes. Our advertising rules guide covers each state’s requirements.
- Measurement. Google’s customer data policies exclude conversions related to the commission or alleged commission of a crime from enhanced conversions.8 Keep charges out of event names and anything else sent to an ad platform: call the event “Lead” or “Qualified,” never “DUI arrest.” Our conversion upload guide covers the policy.
- Mail after an arrest. Rules on writing to people who’ve just been arrested differ by state and have changed over time. The State Bar of Texas says a ban on such mail was removed from the state’s barratry law in 2013, and that the letters must still follow its advertising rules.9 Check your own state before you buy arrest lists.
- Live solicitation. The model rules bar live person-to-person solicitation for a lawyer’s gain, with limited exceptions. Calling back someone who contacted you first is different.
Section 7: Measure criminal defense marketing by charge
Report criminal work on its own line, split the way the cases differ:
- Cost per new client by charge, by the month the inquiry came in: DUI, drugs, theft, assault, other felonies and record clearing.
- Fees per client, by charge and by source.
- Contact rate and speed to lead by hour and day of the week, so nights and weekends show up.
- Calls from someone other than the client, and how often they become clients.
- Consultations booked on the first call, against those booked later.
Section 8: A criminal defense marketing check
Key takeaways
- Police made an estimated 7,570,249 arrests in 2025. Drug violations, DUI and larceny-theft topped the FBI’s list.
- DUI alone was 798,563 arrests, about 2,200 a day.
- Jails reported 7.9 million admissions in the year to June 2024. At midyear, 68% of the people held hadn’t been convicted.
- In fatal crashes in 2024, 31% of drivers at night were alcohol-impaired, against 10% by day, and 28% on weekends against 15% on weekdays.
- About one in five calls to law firms comes after hours. Firms without on-the-spot booking converted 7% of qualified callers then.
- Meta bars ad copy that implies a criminal record, and Google won’t use crime-related conversions in enhanced conversions. Measure in your own records.
Questions
How do criminal defense firms win clients who call at night?
Have a person answer, or call back within minutes, at every hour your ads and listings run, and book the consultation on that call. Run your own numbers through the after-hours check above before you pay for coverage.
Can we run Local Services Ads for criminal defense?
Yes. Criminal, DUI and traffic lawyer services are all Google Local Services categories, where you pay per lead rather than per click. Our Local Services Ads guide covers screening and how leads are charged and credited.
Can a Facebook ad say “Arrested?”
It risks being read as asserting the reader’s criminal record, which Meta’s ad standards bar. Name the service and the place instead: “DUI defense lawyers in Phoenix.” Our Meta ads guide covers the limits.
Can we send letters to people who were just arrested?
It depends on your state, and the rules have changed over time. The State Bar of Texas, for one, says a ban on such mail was removed from the state’s barratry law in 2013, but that the letters must still follow its advertising rules. Check your own state’s current rules before you buy arrest lists or mail anyone.
Should we send signed clients back to Google Ads?
Not through enhanced conversions. Google’s customer data policies exclude conversions related to the commission or alleged commission of a crime. Our conversion upload guide covers the policy.
Sources and notes
Checked November 22, 2026. Numbers in the text link to the source they come from.
-
Federal Bureau of Investigation, Reported Crimes in the Nation, 2025: Quick Stats, released August 2026, from Table 29. Estimates fill in for agencies that didn’t report a full year; traffic citations aren’t counted. ↑
-
Bureau of Justice Statistics, Jail Inmates in 2024 – Statistical Tables, NCJ 311504, September 2026. Admissions count each booking, so one person can be admitted more than once. ↑
-
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Alcohol-Impaired Driving: 2024 Data, Traffic Safety Facts, DOT HS 813 815, June 2026. Night runs from 6 p.m. to 5:59 a.m.; the weekend from Friday 6 p.m. to Monday 5:59 a.m. ↑
-
Smith.ai, The Legal Intake Report, as published by LawSites: “New Data From 3.2 Million Law Firm Calls Reveals What Converts Callers Into Clients,” October 16, 2026. Smith.ai sells answering and intake services. ↑1↑2
-
Google, Getting started with Local Services Ads, Local Services Ads Help, list of eligible categories. ↑
-
Meta, Advertising Standards: Privacy Violations and Personal Attributes, Meta Transparency Center. ↑
-
Meta, About social issues and How ads about social issues, elections or politics are reviewed, Meta Business Help Center. ↑
-
Google, Customer data policies, Advertising Policies Help. ↑
-
State Bar of Texas, Solicitation and Barratry, frequently asked questions. ↑